Breaking it Down: The Differences between Jaw and Impact Crushers

Breaking it Down: The Differences between Jaw and Impact Crushers

When it comes to construction materials processing and demolitions, waste recycling, quarrying, and mining, jaw crushers have been widely used in the domain for decades. They are practically renowned for their robust construction, excellent performance, and low maintenance. As the demand for versatile crushing equipment increases, the need for crushers that can handle different types of materials grows as well. This is where the impact crushers come in. In this article, we will discuss the differences between jaw and impact crushers to help you make a more informed decision.

Jaw Crushers: Jaw crushers are primarily used as primary crushers. Their main purpose is to reduce the material to a small enough size that it can be transported by conveyors to the next crushing stages. As the name suggests, jaw crushers reduce rock and other materials between a fixed and a moving jaw. The moving jaw is mounted on a pitman that has a reciprocating motion, while the fixed jaw remains stationary.

One of the key advantages of jaw crushers is their ability to handle hard and abrasive materials. They excel at processing materials such as granite, basalt, limestone, and recycled concrete. Since jaw crushers are versatile machines, they can crush a wide range of materials depending on the specific application.

Impact Crushers: Impact crushers, on the other hand, are named after the method they use in reducing larger blocks of rocks to smaller grain sizes. As the name suggests, an impact crusher accelerates the feed material to high speed and then flings the fast-moving rocks against the walls of the crushing chamber and each other. This collision, impact, causes the stones to break down to smaller sizes.

One significant difference between these two types of crushers is the way they process materials. Jaw crushers work by compressing and crushing the materials between two moving jaws, while impact crushers use impact to break up the materials. This mechanical pressure is achieved by the two jaws of the crusher.

One notable difference between the two types of crushers is the shape of the plates. Jaw crushers feature a stationary plate and a moving plate, while impact crushers have a rotor and an impact plate. Each of the two is designed to handle different types of materials.

What are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Jaw Crushers? Jaw crushers are highly versatile and are commonly used in the quarrying, mining, building, and demolition industries. The primary advantage of jaw crushers is the maximum feeding size. Jaw crushers crush larger rocks into smaller pieces to fit specific applications. They are typically used as primary crushers to reduce the size of large rocks, and secondary or tertiary crushers to reduce particle sizes down even further.

However, jaw crushers are also known for their disadvantages. Some of them include the following: 1. Heavy and cumbersome construction, requiring heavy operating machinery. 2. Higher purchase and installation costs. 3. Maintenance costs are generally higher. 4. Can handle limited types of materials compared to impact crushers.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Impact Crushers: Impact crushers are ideal for crushing softer, non-abrasive materials such as limestone, coal, gypsum, weathered shales, and phosphate. But HSI crushers are used for recycling hard rock and soft materials. And VSI crushers can handle hard, abrasive materials. In impact crushing, feed material is picked up by a fast moving rotor, greatly accelerated and smashed against an impact plate. Impact crushers can be used as primary crushers, secondary crushers, or tertiary crushers depending on the size and technology.

They are equipped with hammers or blow bars that rotate at high speed, breaking the rocks down into smaller pieces. As the material is broken down by the impacts, it creates a more uniform shape and size.

Like jaw crushers, impact crushers have their advantages and disadvantages. Their advantages include: 1. Reduction ratio of up to 20:1. 2. High crushing ratio and production efficiency. 3. Easy maintenance, with reliable performance.

However, impact crushers are not recommended for use on ores or viscous materials such as clay, as the crushing chamber tends to clog easily. Furthermore, impact crushers are not suitable for crushing hard rocks such as granite and basalt.

In conclusion, jaw crushers are certainly the better choice when it comes to materials processing in mining, construction, and demolition. However, if your business is smaller-scale or deals with softer rocks, an impact crusher might be the best choice for you. Whether you are looking to crush hard materials or need a more uniform shape for reduced maintenance costs, understanding the differences between jaw and impact crushers is crucial for choosing the right equipment for your operation.

You May like:

Contact us